Maxxelli
10/8/2023, 1:17:50 AM

MAXXELLI 2018 CHINA INTERNATIONAL CITY INDEX (CICI)

Monst

Adam McWhirter, GMS-T

Managing Director at Maxxelli


Maxxelli is proud to announce the 4th edition of the China International City Index (CICI), a report that measures the degree of internationalization of China´s emerging second-tier cities. For this edition, we are featuring in-depth research on 29 cities, measuring them across 44 key indicators.

The CICI report

Back in 2015, Maxxelli decided to create the China International City Index for the very first time. Back then, the report featured just 6 cities. These were the cities where we had the largest networks and in-house available data. A year later, we published the second edition of the report and expanded the cities featured to 24. The decision to expand was based on positive feedback of the highly popular initial concept.

If the 2015 CICI was a test run for an idea, then the 2016 CICI was the answer – finally, a way to compare China’s international development across multiple cities and industries through data analysis, not opinion, but by hard facts and data analysis.

CICI 2018 will be similar yet different as it will include ‘’Industry Features’’, an industry analysis that uses the data to compare cities to the featured industry. This year’s report will provide digestible and precise graphical comparisons between the cities. Each chart is accompanied by a concise city “Profile”. This expounds upon what progress the city is making and the direction it is heading in. Where we think the city should and will improve is covered in our “Future Opportunities” section.

Overall China

Ever since China opened up to the world, it has boasted double-digit GDP growth rates for years on end, with a nominal GDP exceeding 12 trillion US dollars in 2017. Ever since 2010, however, this GDP growth rate has stagnated. Note that despite China’s overall stagnation, GDP growth rate in many Chinese second-tier cities are still in double-digits. This is but one example that demonstrates the value second-tier Chinese cities hold in 2018.

An important initiative, launched in 2015, is the Made in China 2025 strategic plan. This plan’s goal is for China to compete in advanced manufacturing. Another key change to look out for here is the proposed scrapping of foreign ownership caps, which limit equity stakes for foreign firms. This policy change will be seen earliest in the automotive industry and in securities ventures.

Second-tier cities

China’s first-tier cities are highly internationalized, with Beijing and Shanghai as prime examples. Other important markets are the second-tier cities, or emerging first-tier cities. These cities represent very interesting business opportunities for foreign enterprises. A specific definition of second-tier cities does not exist, but at the very least there is a minimum GDP and population per tier.

Maxxelli finds that calling a city second-tier is not a very descriptive definition. With this report, Maxxelli classifies cities by their internationalization, which offers a broader more in-depth analysis. To summarize, Maxxelli defines cities as second-tier cities if they show a large population, a strong economy and are internationalized across a number of indicators.

Internationalization

If cities show a higher degree of internationalization, they hold greater appeal for foreign companies due to their increased market potential, accessibility, livability and growth prospects. Second-tier cities are becoming more and more international. In the CICI, Maxxelli measures a city’s degree of internationalization based on seven categories: Global Economic Strength, International Commerce, Education, International Community, Infrastructural Connectivity, Government and Political Engagement, and Culture and Tourism. These seven categories are explained more in detail in the methodology section at the end of this report.

Click the picture below to read the full report

2018-CICI.pdf 1.12 MB


2018-CICI.pdf
1.1698 mb
Monst
Adam McWhirter, GMS-T

Managing Director at Maxxelli

Joined Maxxelli in 2008, I am currently the Managing Partner. If you have any queries about our services, please do not hesitate to reach out to me directly a.mcwhirter@maxxelli-consulting.com

Latest articles

Interesting articles

blog
article
Bangkok's Metro Guide

Bangkok's Metro Guide Bangkok, the bustling capital of Thailand, is a city of contrasts. From its vibrant street markets and historic temples to its modern skyscrapers and corporate hubs, the city offers a unique blend of tradition and modernity. For corporate expats living and working in Bangkok, navigating the city’s traffic can be a daunting task. Fortunately, the Bangkok Metro System provides a reliable and efficient way to get around. In this article, we’ll explore the history and evolution of the metro system, how to use it, and the details of its private ownership and dual-system operation. The History and Evolution of the Bangkok Metro System Bangkok’s metro system is a relatively recent development, especially when compared to other major cities in Asia. The city’s rapid urbanization in the late 20th century led to severe traffic congestion, prompting the need for a mass transit solution. The first step toward this goal was the opening of the BTS Skytrain in 1999. Operated by Bangkok Mass Transit System (BTSC), the Skytrain is an elevated rail system that serves as the backbone of Bangkok’s public transportation. The success of the BTS Skytrain paved the way for the development of the MRT (Metropolitan Rapid Transit), which opened in 2004. Unlike the Skytrain, the MRT is an underground subway system that complements the BTS by covering different parts of the city. Over the years, both systems have expanded, with new lines and extensions being added to meet the growing demand. In 2021, the Airport Rail Link (ARL) was integrated into the network, providing a direct connection between Suvarnabhumi Airport and the city center. Additionally, the Gold Line, a monorail system, was introduced to serve specific areas, further enhancing connectivity. Today, Bangkok’s metro system is a vital part of the city’s infrastructure, offering a fast, air-conditioned, and a relatively affordable alternative to the notorious traffic jams. How to Use the Bangkok Metro System Using the Bangkok Metro System is straightforward, but it’s important to understand the differences between the two main systems: the BTS Skytrain and the MRT. 1. BTS Skytrain • Lines: The BTS operates two main lines: the Sukhumvit Line (light green) and the Silom Line (dark green). These lines intersect at Siam Station, the central hub of the network. • Tickets: Single-journey tickets can be purchased at vending machines in stations. For frequent travelers, consider getting a Rabbit Card, a rechargeable smart card that offers convenience and discounts. • Operating Hours: The BTS runs from approximately 6:00 AM to midnight, depending on the station. • Key Stations: Siam (shopping hub), Asok (connection to MRT), and Mo Chit (access to Chatuchak Weekend Market). 2. MRT (Metropolitan Rapid Transit) • Lines: The MRT currently operates two lines: the Blue Line and the Purple Line. The Blue Line is the most extensive, connecting northern and southern parts of the city. • Tickets: Similar to the BTS, single-journey tickets are available at vending machines. The MRT Plus Card is a rechargeable option for regular users. • Operating Hours: The MRT operates from around 6:00 AM to midnight. • Key Stations: Hua Lamphong (central railway station), Chatuchak Park (connection to BTS), and Sukhumvit (connection to BTS). 3. Transfers Between BTS and MRT While the BTS and MRT are operated by different companies, they are designed to complement each other. Key transfer points include: • Asok Station: BTS Sukhumvit Line to MRT Sukhumvit Station. • Mo Chit Station: BTS Sukhumvit Line to MRT Chatuchak Park Station. • Silom Station: BTS Silom Line to MRT Si Lom Station. Note that transfers between the two systems require exiting one system and re-entering the other, meaning you’ll need to purchase separate tickets unless you have a multi-system card like the BTS-MRT Joint Pass. Private Ownership and Dual-System Operation One unique aspect of Bangkok’s metro system is its private ownership. Unlike many other cities where public transportation is government-operated, Bangkok’s metro systems are run by private companies: • BTS Skytrain: Operated by Bangkok Mass Transit System (BTSC), a private company. • MRT: Operated by Bangkok Expressway and Metro Public Company Limited (BEM), another private entity. This private ownership has led to a competitive environment, with both companies striving to improve services and expand their networks. However, it also means that the systems are not fully integrated, requiring passengers to navigate separate ticketing systems and transfer points. Tips: 1. Plan Your Route: Use apps like Google Maps or ViaBus to plan your journey and check real-time updates. 2. Avoid Peak Hours: The metro can get crowded during rush hours (7:00–9:00 AM and 5:00–7:00 PM). Plan your travel accordingly. 3. Carry Small Change: Vending machines often require exact change for single-journey tickets. 4. Learn Basic Thai Phrases: While most signs and announcements are in English, knowing basic Thai can be helpful. 5. Explore the City: The metro system provides easy access to major attractions, shopping malls, and business districts. Conclusion Bangkok’s metro system has come a long way since its inception, evolving into a modern and efficient network that serves millions of passengers daily. For corporate expats, mastering the BTS and MRT is key to navigating the city with ease. By understanding the history, operation, and nuances of the system, you’ll be well-equipped to make the most of your time in this dynamic metropolis. Whether you’re commuting to work or exploring the city’s vibrant culture, the Bangkok Metro System is your gateway to a seamless urban experience.

blog
general
What's a Mooncake?

As the Mid-Autumn Festival approaches, the allure of mooncakes captivates millions, transcending generations and time. These iconic pastries aren't merely festive treats but symbols of prosperity, family reunion, and cultural heritage. As integral as they are to the festival’s traditions, mooncakes have also evolved into a flourishing industry with a compelling blend of history, economic significance, and future potential. [Mooncake & Tea] The Historical Roots and Gifting Etiquette A Time-honored Tradition Mooncakes have been synonymous with the Mid-Autumn Festival for over a millennium, dating back to the Tang Dynasty (618–907 AD). Initially, they were used as offerings to the moon and later became a customary snack during celebrations. Associated with mystical tales like that of Chang'e, the Moon Goddess, mooncakes embody themes of reunion, completeness, and festivity. The Art of Gifting In contemporary China, mooncakes are not only enjoyed as a culinary delight but are also an essential element of the festival’s gifting etiquette. Presenting mooncakes to family, friends, and business associates is a gesture of respect and goodwill. Traditional boxes are often richly adorned, underscoring the value and joy of the gift. Notably, mooncakes are best given a few days before the festival begins, allowing recipients time to appreciate and enjoy them during family gatherings under the luminous full moon. Sales Statistics and Trends: A Decade of Growth An Ever-expanding Market The mooncake industry has seen substantial growth over the past decade, driven by factors such as urbanization, increased disposable income, and the expanding middle class. In 2013, mooncake sales in China were approximately $1.2 billion. By 2022, this figure had tripled to over $3.2 billion, indicating a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of roughly 10%.  Record-Breaking 2023 Sales 2023 witnessed another remarkable year for the mooncake industry, with sales surpassing $3.5 billion, marking a 7% increase from the previous year. The growth trajectory not only reflects domestic consumption but also embodies the industry's global reach, with a notable increase in exports catering to the Chinese diaspora and international enthusiasts of Asian cuisine. Influence of Large Brands and High-profile Collaborations Innovation Luxury brands and high-profile collaborations have dramatically influenced the mooncake market. Companies like Starbucks, Häagen-Dazs, and Godiva have introduced unique mooncake offerings, blending traditional ingredients with contemporary flavors like matcha, coffee, and chocolate. Celebrity Endorsements and Designer Packaging Another significant trend is the partnership between mooncake manufacturers and fashion designers or celebrities. For instance, in recent years, Mao Tai and Max Mara co-branded mooncakes that featured exquisite packaging designed by the Italian fashion house, making them standout gift choices. Such collaborations enhance the appeal of mooncakes, especially among younger consumers who value high aesthetic and brand recognition. Mooncake E-commerce Boom Platforms like Alibaba and JD.com have driven the e-commerce mooncake surge, offering consumers convenient access to a variety of brands and flavors. Online pre-sales often see sales records being broken, as people prefer the convenience of having these celebratory delicacies delivered to their doorsteps. Projections for 2024: A Bright Future Ahead Market Sustained Growth With the Mid-Autumn Festival secure in its role as a pivotal cultural event, industry analysts project mooncake sales to approach or exceed the $4 billion mark in 2024. Emerging markets, including those within Southeast Asia and among the global Chinese market, are anticipated to contribute to this growth. Sustainable and Health-Conscious Trends Adding to this growth trajectory are trends emphasizing sustainability and health. Consumers are becoming increasingly conscious of packaging waste and the caloric content of traditional mooncakes. This has nudged producers towards developing eco-friendly packaging and low-sugar, low-fat alternatives, broadening their demographic appeal. Companies making strides in providing healthier options, including those using organic ingredients, are poised to gain significant market share. Innovative Flavors and Formats Fruit and nut varieties, frozen mooncake innovations (such as ice cream-filled mooncakes), and even vegan options are expected to continue expanding their foothold in the market. Furthermore, engagement with augmented and virtual reality experiences linked to these delicacies could appeal to tech-savvy consumers. Cultural Heritage Meets Modernity As mooncakes continue to stand at the confluence of tradition and innovation, one thing remains clear: they are much more than baked goods. They are carriers of culture, embodiments of seasonal joy, and fascinating examples of how reluctant heritage can propel an industry year after year. In conclusion, as we look forward to the Mid-Autumn Festival in 2024 and beyond, it is evident that mooncakes will not only continue to be a linchpin in the celebration but will also keep evolving in ways that honor their rich history while embracing the future. The mooncake industry, bursting with potential, promises more delicious innovations that will keep both our taste buds and traditions alive.

blog
general
Full Moon Festival

As we approach the Full Moon or Autumn Festival, also known as the Mid-Autumn Festival, it's time to delve into the rich history, traditions, and cultural significance of this cherished holiday in China. Beyond its historical roots and vibrant customs, the festival has given rise to a booming industry centered around its most iconic delicacy: the mooncake. [Full Moon 2024] A Glimpse into the History The Mid-Autumn Festival, celebrated on the 15th day of the eighth lunar month, is a time-honored tradition in Chinese culture, dating back over 3,000 years. It correlates with the autumn equinox when the moon is believed to be at its fullest and brightest. Initially an occasion to worship the moon and express gratitude for the autumn harvest, the festival has evolved into a broader celebration of unity, family, and bounty. The origins of the Mid-Autumn Festival are steeped in folklore. One of the most popular legends is that of Chang'e, the Moon Goddess. According to the tale, Chang'e swallowed an immortality elixir and ascended to the moon, where she continues to live to this day. During the festival, devoted families set up altars to honor Chang'e, believing that she brings blessings of harmony and prosperity. Traditions and Customs  Moon Gazing One of the festival’s most evocative traditions is moon gazing. Families gather outdoors to admire the luminous full moon, an experience often accompanied by heartfelt conversations, shared memories, and the symbolic aspiration for reunion and completeness. Lanterns Colorful paper lanterns, carrying good wishes, are lit in homes and public spaces. They come in myriad shapes and sizes, illuminating nights with their soft, enchanting glow. Children carry these lanterns and play moonlight games, contributing to the festival's festive spirit. Dragon and Lion Dances In many parts of China, the Autumn Festival also features dragon and lion dances. These exhilarating performances, accompanied by rhythmic drumming and gongs, are not only mean to entertain but also to usher in good luck and drive away evil spirits. Mooncakes: The Heart of the Mid-Autumn Feast No discussion of the Mid-Autumn Festival is complete without mentioning mooncakes. These round pastries symbolize the full moon and the reunion of families. Traditionally, mooncakes have a dense filling made of lotus seed paste, with yolks of salted duck eggs embedded representing the full moon. Modern variations now include a plethora of fillings such as red bean paste, taro, mixed nuts, and even contemporary innovations like chocolate or ice cream. The Mooncake Industry The demand for mooncakes soars as the festival nears, making it a significant industry in China. According to recent statistics, 2023 saw impressive sales figures, highlighting the industry's expansive growth. The mooncake market in China surpassed $3.5 billion in sales, reflecting an increase of about 7% from the previous year. This growth is driven by both traditional preferences and new, innovative varieties that cater to evolving tastes and global palates. Luxury mooncake gift boxes – adorned with intricate designs and often including high-end ingredients like bird's nest or gold flakes – are immensely popular. Major brands collaborate with international designers to create aesthetically appealing packaging, making mooncakes not just edible delights but cherished gifts. Businesses and corporations also capitalize on the festival, using mooncakes as a means to foster relationships and express gratitude to clients and employees. The Essence of Celebration: Family and Unity While mooncakes and festivities captivate with their charm and flavor, the essence of the Mid-Autumn Festival lies in the bonds it strengthens. For many, it is a rare opportunity to reunite with family members scattered across cities or even continents. The act of sharing a mooncake, quintessentially round, mirrors the wholeness and unity aspired by families. The Full Moon or Mid-Autumn Festival is a testament to China's rich cultural heritage and the power of tradition in forging the communal spirit. Whether it’s through the glow of lanterns, awe-inspiring legends, or the savory-sweet taste of mooncakes, the festival is a glorious manifestation of togetherness, gratitude, and celebration. As we carve out moments beneath the full moon this season, it's a beautiful reminder of both the ancient stories that bind us and the enduring love that connects us, illuminating our shared humanity even in the most modern of times.